Ensure Fall Protection Equipment is Inspected

In an interesting California Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board reconsideration, a serious violation citation was upheld for a company’s failure to properly inspect fall protection arrest systems prior to use.

Cal/OSHA Construction Safety Order Personal Fall Arrest Systems, Personal Fall Restraint Systems and Positioning Devices (8 CCR § 1670(b)(15)) states, “Personal fall arrest systems must be inspected prior to each use for wear, damage, and other deterioration and defective components shall be removed from service”. Also, a defect is defined in Cal/OSHA Construction Safety Order Definitions (8 CCR § 1504) as “Any characteristic or condition which tends to weaken or reduce the strength or the safety of the tool, machine, object, or structure of which it is a part.”

In this case, lanyards had been used by the workers earlier in the day and it appears (according to the administrative law judge) that the employees had indeed inspected the lanyards prior to use. So, what went wrong and why the serious violation? Later that day a Cal/OSHA inspector arrived at the job site and upon examination of the lanyards found a defect with the snap hooks. While the employees, including the foreman charged with safety concerns had conducted an inspection, it was cursory, and they failed to test the snap hooks on the lanyard by pulling them back wide and releasing the button.

The employer argued that even if the snap hooks were used in their defective state, they did not expose employees to a potential fall hazard. However, from a previous Appeals Board decision Cal/OSHA need only prove that a condition or practice prohibited by a safety order exists. The purpose of the snap hook is to connect the worker to fall protection, thus it was determined a defective snap hook exposes an employee to a potential fall hazard and since the workers were working from a height of 130 feet the probability of a serious injury or death exists.

In order to uphold an alleged violation as “serious”, the Division normally offers evidence of employer’s knowledge that it knew of the violation or could have known with the exercise of reasonable diligence. Does the foreman or supervisor who is responsible for employee safety and supervision have knowledge or should have knowledge of the hazard? In this case it was determined he did or should have.

Bottom Line: Ensure your inspections are conducted and complete, this would apply for any equipment where inspections are required including scaffolding, shoring, forklifts, machine guards, ladders, personal protective equipment — the list goes on and on. Make sure that the equipment is closely examined and that a defect or unsafe condition doesn’t exist and if present that the equipment is immediately taken out of service. Also confirm you can demonstrate (usually by documentation) that the inspections were performed.

 

Note: This information was provided by Tim Bormann, CIH, FAIHA, The Cohen Group

Recent Posts

SCGMA ConstructConnect Live Demo

Join us for a live demo with ConstructConnect, the leading preconstruction platform that helps commercial construction professionals find more projects, bid smarter, and work faster. Date: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 Time: 11:00am – 12:00pm Location: via Zoom Key Takeaways: Access 750,000+ active…

October 8, 2025

SCGMA AI for Personal Productivity & Firm Transformation Workshop

In this fast-paced, hands-on workshop, AI consultant Stjepan Mikulic will help you turn AI into measurable results—both personally and across your entire firm. You’ll learn how to create custom GPTs, use AI to build presentations, visuals, and reports. Then, we’ll…

September 24, 2025

SCGMA Technical Bulletin – True Divided Lite Glazing Versus Simulated

The glazing industry has always responded to architect’s desire for enhanced glazing details, providing options that meet the design intent and address budget constraints.  Such is the case of divided lite window glazing, the subject of this Technical Bulletin. Divided…

September 22, 2025

SCGMA Document Crunch Live Demo

Join us for a live demo of Document Crunch, the industry’s leading AI-powered risk platform built to simplify complex contracts and project documents, accelerate decision-making, and keep projects moving forward. Document Crunch empowers your team to quickly review contracts, specifications,…

September 10, 2025

SCGMA YPG 2025 Glazing Boot Camp & Water Testing Demo

Join us for our 2025 Glazing Boot Camp at the Apprenticeship Training Facility in Commerce. This session will provide a hands-on learning experience as participants work alongside our apprentices to build storefront and curtainwall mockups, while exploring key installation techniques…

August 27, 2025
MORE STORIES